Tuesday, January 1, 2013


Appeal from a Law student in America at the University of London International Programmes

My name is Moshe (Jeff) Admon. I am a law student from the United States entering my 3rd year of the LL.B. (Laws) degree from the University of London International Programmes.  I study completely independently and without guidance or assistance from teachers or tutors, and currently have a scholastic average of 2:1. 

We the students of the International Programmes are a very diverse group from multiple nations throughout the world, but share an admiration for the great English legal tradition of common law which is founded upon the most basic right of openness and public debate.  

Undoubtedly, the substantial quality of the education we receive is of the highest quality.  Yet, I write this letter because I feel that since the beginning of my studies, I have been repeatedly wronged by my University in the MOST CRUCIAL part of my studies – my grading.  

After my first year results, I felt that I was not awarded the marks which I deserved, and formally asked the University to publicize (with anonymity) papers of students that received 1:1 marks to serve as a guide for the rest of us who make genuine efforts in our learning.  My request was refused and the policy stubbornly continues. 

This year, despite my enormous efforts and colossal investment of time into my studies, I was crushed by the results awarded to me, particularly in the subject of Trusts/Equity in which I was exceptionally prepared and constantly active in our online class discussion (as many of my fellow classmates were).  I protested these results, and for reasons of “academic policy”, the University adamantly refuses to send me graded copies of exams with remarks by the mysterious examiners explaining to me where I erred and thus how to improve my grades in the coming year.  I find this policy unjust and educationally wrong.

Compounding to this deplorable policy, students are DENIED the most basic right to appeal results on academic grounds and low marks remain an unquestionable and irrevocable stain on our record for the rest of our lives, and thus our futures in the legal profession are in many ways decided in secrecy and darkness.

Additionally, and especially pronounced, the University will not publicize its marking guidelines for exams, and only provides a very broad "assessment criteria" upon which grades are determined, leaving students in the dark regarding the benchmark upon which our exams are marked.  Couples with the University's refusal to publish anonymous 1:1 results in full, this policy leaves students grasping for straws in regards to improving academic performance, a wholly anti-pedagogical approach to the educational principles which any University should espouse. 

Therefore, I hereby appeal to every student in the University that feels wronged to call for a change in the existing policy of grading and reviewing exams to make it open and transparent in order for us to improve our academic performance.  I hereby provide an open platform for everyone that feels wronged by the present school policies to express themselves openly and hope the University will heed of our reasonable and justified complaints. In the spirit of openness I request that anyone who posts on this site state their name and location.

While we are judged in the dark, I am publicizing this letter and all that accompanies it so YOU can be a jury in the light.

We call for openness!

My story, despite its length, is a worthwhile reading and hopefully will encourage you, my fellow classmates and other students throughout the world, to speak up for our rights.


Moshe (Jeff) Admon, B.Sc., B.A.
LL.B. Candidate 2013, University of London International Programmes

No comments:

Post a Comment